Re: Peter Himmelman

[Martin Grossman <tgg...>]

>   hebass (at) JTSA(dot)EDU writes:
>  The original of this message is not Matthew's.  I am using this quote 
>  from his message because it was the first time I saw it.
>  
>  The contents of this message are not musical, but Jewish.  They only 
>  appear in this list because they are a response to something that 
>  appeared here before.
>  
>  
>  On Thu, 22 Jun 1995, Matthew H. Fields wrote:
>  
>  > In article <3sbvrl$k32 (at) rover(dot)ucs(dot)ualberta(dot)ca>,
>  > P. Kirman <pkirman (at) gpu(dot)srv(dot)ualberta(dot)ca> wrote:
>  > [...]
>  > >is a supporter of the Chabad, does not make his children 
>  > >Halachically Jewish, and so, technically, Peter's children 
>  > >are not Jewish either unless Maria has had an Orthodox conversion.
>
I must have missed something here. Perhaps while I was out of town. This whole 
thing is rather silly, especially since Sara Dylan, 
Maria's mother (the former Shirley Nozinsky or soemthing like that), is a far 
as I know "halachically" Jewish. Who says otherwise. And 
why do you care? Himmelman, I'm sure, is raising Jewish children.