Mail Archive sponsored by
Chazzanut Online
jewish-music
Hava nagila
- From: Solidarity Foundation <svzandt...>
- Subject: Hava nagila
- Date: Mon 16 Mar 1998 16.08 (GMT)
Moshe,
I once discussed this with a Lubovicher. He told me they didn't
sing it any more because they considered the tune had now become _treyf_,
it was so secularized. Another person, not a _husid_ but very knoweledgeable
about Jewish music, told me, yes it may have been a nign among the
Lubovicher (Chabadniks), but not specific to them. I don't know what text
they sung it to -- certainly not Hava nagila", which is secular.
Itzik-Leyb
Lastly, I have heard that Hava Nagila is an old Chabad Nign, but the Chabazkers
don't sing it because of their Rebbe's forbidding.
has someone else heard about it?
Moshe Berlin
- Hava nagila,
Solidarity Foundation