Re: syntax question (liner notes)

[ALANEFALK <ALANEFALK...>]

In a message dated 9/12/02 11:36:04 AM, AGREENBA (at) aol(dot)com writes:

<< Okay, I'll vote:
"on" sounds right to me. You have recorded pieces onto a disk, on an album. I 
think a photo album has photos "in" it but a recording as tunes "on" it.
Adrianne >>

I'm with Adrianne - 
'on' - even though the grooves on a CD have been laser cut 'in' to the 
plastic! (Just like old vynal records)
I guess you could equally argue that they are therefore not with 'in' the 
plastic itself but 'on' the surface!   . . . .  senior rambling moment -  
Sounds like a question one would poise to a Yeshiva bocher!!!!
correct syntax - in.
Alan Falk
Nefesh Klezmer Band

---------------------- jewish-music (at) shamash(dot)org ---------------------+