Mail Archive sponsored by
Chazzanut Online
hanashir
[HANASHIR:1746] Re: Politically Incorrect
- From: DurlKare <DurlKare...>
- Subject: [HANASHIR:1746] Re: Politically Incorrect
- Date: Wed 11 Nov 1998 04.01 (GMT)
In a message dated 11/10/98 08:05:58 Central Standard Time, LSOLKOWITZ (at)
aol(dot)com
writes:
<< I'm now a member of (and music teacher for) and Orthodox / Lubavich
congregation and school. We only use Ha-Shem and Ado-Shem in songs (we avoid
the English terms all together). I've been wondering how the composers on
this list would feel with this substitution, not only for Rise & Shine, but
for their works as well. Without the substitution, our Rabbi will not permit
the songs to be used.
Personally, I find this substitution to be respectful and politically
correct.
What do y'all think??
>>
I use "Hashem" in my "Y'varech'cha" song, which has actually caused me some
grief in Reform circles. It just fits the whole mood of the song better, and
my emotional/spiritual mood when I wrote the song. I would of course use
Hashem or Adoshem when singing any of my songs for any group who would be
offended by using another name, and I would expect others to do the same. I
grew up in an Orthodox/Lubavitch run day school and so this feels natural. In
fact it took getting used to saying Adonai in songs. But now that feels
natural too. My feeling now is that there are different names for God and
each has a different feeling to me.
By the way, do you teach all girls? And do you teach some of the "modern"
stuff?
-Karen D.
- [HANASHIR:1746] Re: Politically Incorrect,
DurlKare