Re: Viktor Ullman

[Ruth Rose <rose678...>]

>I just have a difficult time with
>setting up criteria to exclude the work of Jewish composers from being
>"Jewish" music.  As for myself, being a communist (Trotskyist) and therefore
>an atheist, my second generation identity is far stronger than my "Jewish"
>identity, so if people don't consider me or my music Jewish, I don't mind.
> However, perhaps in typical second generation fashion, I immediately rush to
>the defense of anyone of my parent's generation.

Exactly my point, Jeff. As far as I'm concerned, these great composers have
their well-deserved place in Jewish music. But as you've applied the
situation to yourself, I believe you've answered your own questions up
there. And I appreciate you letting me know where you're coming from. I'd
like to know more about the music you make.

>Setting different standards out of a sense of solidarity towards
>these composers' tragic destiny takes away from the integrity of this or any
>other discussion.

>>Hear hear! cq. David Helfgott

Again, exactly my point. Thanks, Seth! (are you a mind reader?)

Ruth