Re: Reply to Isabelle : Re: Moni Ovadia

[eliott kahn <elkahn...>]

Dear Ms. Ganz:

Thank you so much for lending your informed opinion on vocal production to 
this list. It's of great value to all List members to receive accurate 
information, so we may all speak objectively and honestly about Jewish music.

Good Shabbes,



At 12:41 AM 2/18/00 -0500, you wrote:
>Dear Jacob,
>
>There doesn't seem much point in putting on punching gloves for such an
>issue.  Just to comment on your definition of "standard" vocalization being
>the same volume as one's speaking voice, or when singing "Happy Birthday"
>to a child: speaking almost never has a pitch range as large as an octave,
>which is the range of "Happy Birthday".  The larger range used in singing
>carries further  than the smaller speaking range, even if the voice in
>question is untrained.
>
>Genuk shoyn.  All the best,
>
>Isabelle
>
>---------------------- jewish-music (at) shamash(dot)org ---------------------+
>