[HANASHIR:5061] Re: Performance vs. praying

[Chazzzan <Chazzzan...>]

I didn't want to appear judgmental about whether one method is better than 
another.  There is nothing wrong with a "performance" per se.  That is just not 
the kind of service that I want to have every week. 

I have worked with Jewish children (and adults) for many years.  I have always 
tried to understand what turns them off or turns them on about attending 
services.  My concern was that if kids got turned off to attending services, 
their negative attitude could last a lifetime, and would color their adult 
attitude toward Judaism and synagogue affiliation. 

On the other hand, if I could excite them and motivate them when they came to 
services, I was certain that this positive experience would be remembered when 
they became adults. 

We had terrific leaders in our Junior Congregation when I was growing 
up...leaders who inspired us to participate, to sing, to get involved.  I 
waited with anticipation for Shabbat and the fun and camaraderie...That is the 
kind of experience I want to give all who show up -- adults or children.

Is this asking too much in today's fast-paced MTV world?
I don't think so....Craig Taubman captured the congregation and held it in his 
sway for the entire evening.  Nobody went away bored from that service!  Most 
were still humming his Lecha Dodi as they put on their coats and shuffled out 
into the dark frigid night.

Brian Serle
Milwaukee, Wisconsin (1/2 inch north of Chicago)


------------------------ hanashir (at) shamash(dot)org -----------------------+